Is it Comprehensive or uninsured motorist Collision

by velu » Tue Jun 16, 2009 08:03 pm
Posts: 16
Joined: 08 May 2008

Somebody made a dent and a deep scratch in my parked car, I dont know who did it...I noticed it after 2 days. I reported it to my insurance thinking it wud come under comrehensive(100$ deductible), but they wanted to go under uninsured motorist collision (250$ deductible). Can I ask them to do under comprehensive?!am I eligible for it?

I have 3 estimates for the damage
Dealer 1 Estimate: 731$ (Initial quote)
Dealer 2 Estimate: 1672$
Insurance Estimate: 936$- 250$ deductible= 686$
If I get a check for 936$ and get that work done from dealer 1 (731$), if dealer 1 claims there are more damages to the car, will it end up in me paying for the rest of the damage or can I again go back to insurance and ask them to deal with dealer 1?!
Thanks for your answers

Total Comments: 16

Posted: Tue Jun 16, 2009 11:02 pm Post Subject: comp or uninsured motorist claim

If you don't know who hit you. What hit you. Than the insurance company shouldn"t tell you it's a Uninsured Motortist claim. They can't prove who ever hit you was insured at the time, or not. Or if it was a car that even hit you.

Posted: Tue Jun 16, 2009 11:51 pm Post Subject: Comprehensive or collision claim

Reguarding the Actual Damage issue. If there is more damage found to your vehicle, after the inital Appraisal. The Insurance company will have a Supplemental Appraisal done by the adjuster. The additional damage amount should be sent to you or the body shop to peform the additional repairs.

Posted: Wed Jun 17, 2009 12:21 am Post Subject:

No such thing as uninsured motorist collision. It's either collision or uninsured motorist property damage.

In either case, if it was another vehicle that caused the dent then it's collision or UMPD. If it was some type of vandalism or an object fell on the vehicle then it's comprehensive coverage.

The insurance company is going to look at the location of the dent as well as it's size and shape to determine what caused it.

A few things come to mind... door dent (collision), dent from a shopping cart (collision), dent from a bat or other hand held object (comprehensive), large rock... doubtful (comprehensive).

They can't prove who ever hit you was insured at the time

If the person is not known they meet the definition of not being insured, hence "Uninsured".

Posted: Wed Jun 17, 2009 12:37 am Post Subject:

It is Uninsured Motorist Coverage, not Uninsured Anything or Anybody coverage.hence the term Uninsured]Motorist.

Posted: Wed Jun 17, 2009 07:33 am Post Subject:

Hey Velu,

Somebody made a dent and a deep scratch in my parked car,



Are you sure that it happened when the car was parked? I'm asking this since you went unaware of the damage for 2 days.

Can it be possible that you were hit during traffic and might not realize?

Posted: Wed Jun 17, 2009 01:04 pm Post Subject:

Dear BestConnectionInsurance..

The Insurance company will have a Supplemental Appraisal done by the adjuster.



I got your point. But how's this supplemental appraisal different from the initial one?

Does it involve another adjuster?

Steven

Posted: Wed Jun 17, 2009 04:15 pm Post Subject: Is it Comprehensive or uninsured motorist Collision

No I didnt hit anything.I spoke to my insurance they said, they will discuss with the material damage evaluation person. somebody said...If I go by comprehensive, it will affect my claims history and if I go by uninsured motorist coverage it wont! Is it so?!

Posted: Wed Jun 17, 2009 04:45 pm Post Subject:

Usually either comp or UMPD won't affect rates unless there are multiple claims within a short amount of time.

Posted: Thu Jun 18, 2009 03:57 am Post Subject:

No I didnt hit anything.



Okay Velu, thanks for clarifying it.

If I go by comprehensive, it will affect my claims history and if I go by uninsured motorist coverage it wont!



Well, all claims that you would made would go into the CLUE report. Even enquiries made with the insurer might show up in your claim history as well. But as Tcope has said collision/comprehensive or UMPD won't affect your premium rate.

By the way, has the insurer sent out the appraiser to look at the dent?

As someone has mentioned earlier an adjuster would be able to determine what might have caused the damage. If it has been caused by another vehicle, you may have to file it under UMPD. But if it suggests vandalism, then you need to file under comprehensive.

if dealer 1 claims there are more damages to the car, will it end up in me paying for the rest of the damage



Why do you suspect that there would be more damages to the vehicle then the one you are filing the claim for? Are there unrepaired prior damages to the car?

Add your comment

Enter the characters shown in the image.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.