Should I Try To Convince My Insurance To Total Or Repair?

by bestpolicypartner » Mon Dec 18, 2017 06:03 pm

I have a 2008 Toyota Camry that's in... less than ideal condition. I live in Long Island, and spend most of my time in Brooklyn, New York.

It has 105,000 miles on it or so. I've owned it since I bought it in 2007 (although at one point the title was in a friend's name for a few years near the beginning of its life, while I only had a permit)

The interior is pretty dirty, and has a few small issues that are easily fix-up-able

The right side is scratched up, has a dent that makes the front right door have issues, and needs a new mirror

Both bumpers have dings, dents. A rear light has missing plexiglass on it.

I was recently in a small accident that caused the front left bumper to be dented, and has damaged the suspension / shocks / steering in some capacity (it thinks it's driving straight when the steering wheel is crooked, turning feels strange, some noises from the shocks)

My deductible is $200

The insurance assessor thought it might end up being totaled because of the suspension issues, but that given its (apparently low?) milage, it might end up being saved

Do I want it to be totaled? With a car in this condition, would I be able to get a reasonable amount back from it - enough to buy a used car in good enough condition to replace the car I've been driving?

Or should I try to convince the insurance adjustor not to total it?

Total Comments: 2

Posted: Mon Dec 18, 2017 06:31 pm Post Subject: Clarification

To be super clear about my question:

The insurance adjustor seemed a fairly sympathetic person

If I can say something now that would convince him to either go ahead with a covered repair, or to go ahead and total it and give me a check, which seems the more preferable option in my scenario?

I.e. would totalling it and cutting me a check likely afford me a vehicle that's in as good / useable condition (and maybe better aesthetic condition) than my current car?

If not, it makes more sense for me to try to sway him towards a repair, no?

Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2018 12:49 pm Post Subject: Insurance

Previous post is totally right - you're paying your insurance and they have to provide you with all that included, so be aware. And dont look for anonymous car insurance

Add your comment

Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.